In Gerard McLean & Anor v Winchester Medical Aesthetics Limited [2026] EWHC 2941 (TCC), the Technology and Construction Court granted summary judgment in favour of an adjudicator for his unpaid fees under the agreed terms of his appointment, ruling that the fees had been reasonably incurred. Additionally, the Court allowed the adjudicator his time spent pursuing payment, interest and legal costs.
Background
Following agreements between Winchester Medical Aesthetics Limited (“Winchester Medical”) and Archiproject Limited (“Archiproject”), a construction contract was entered into between the parties. In around November 2024, the contract was terminated, and a dispute arose over the adequacy of the construction work carried out by Archiproject.
On 21 January 2025, Winchester Medical sent a notice of adjudication to Archiproject (the “Notice”). In the Notice, Winchester Medical sought a refund of over £25,000 it had paid Archiproject for works carried out. The adjudicator, Gerard McLean, was nominated by RIBA on 23 January 2025, and both parties agreed to his terms. The terms specifically provided that the parties would be jointly and severally liable for the fees and expenses incurred and interest would accrue at 8% above the base rate on outstanding payment of the fees. They also entitled the adjudicator to his costs incurred in pursuing unpaid invoices and to all legal costs incurred in recovering outstanding fees.
On 7 March 2025, the adjudicator provided the parties with his decision but did not receive payment for his services. Proceedings to recover the outstanding fees were commenced on 7 November 2025 by the adjudicator and his company, Expert Architect Studio LLP (the “Claimants”), which eventually applied for summary judgment. Winchester Medical resisted the claim on numerous grounds, including that the adjudicator’s fees were unreasonable and inflated and that his appointment terms were unfair, rendering the fees unrecoverable.
The court’s decision
The Judge, HHJ Kelly, ruled that none of Winchester Medical’s arguments had any realistic prospect of success and awarded summary judgment for the Claimants. In doing so, the Court affirmed key principles regarding the payment of adjudicator’s fees.
It was held that the adjudicator’s terms and conditions had been fairly set out and provided to the parties and that Winchester Medical could have refused the appointment if it had an issue with any of the adjudicator’s terms. Additionally, the Judge confirmed that the provision making the parties jointly and severally liable for the payment of the adjudicator’s fees was not “onerous or unusual” at all, and that the adjudicator was contractually entitled to payment for time reasonably spent dealing with the adjudication at the agreed hourly rate.
Further, the adjudicator’s fees were held to be recoverable. The Judge found that the hours recorded in the Claimants’ contemporaneous timesheets were reasonable and that there was no evidence that the fees had been inflated or that the work could have been completed more quickly, as Winchester Medical alleged. The Judge also accepted the Claimants’ evidence that a vast number of documents had been submitted to the adjudicator during the adjudication, many of which the Judge agreed were irrelevant but that the adjudicator needed to examine. Therefore, the Court awarded the full £14,113.44 of outstanding fees in favour of the Claimants.
The Judge awarded interest on top of the outstanding fees at 8% above the base rate, which was reflected in the terms of the adjudicator’s appointment. Further, the Claimants were also entitled to recover costs of their own time spent pursuing the unpaid invoices, which totalled £5,093.28 up to the date of the application for summary judgment and £1,671.84 for work undertaken following the application. Separately, the Claimants claimed their full legal costs of £37,664.30, which they were entitled to recover under the terms and conditions (significantly more than the original fee sought). The Judge confirmed that those legal costs had been reasonably incurred throughout the proceedings, especially in relation to addressing Winchester Medical’s wide-ranging and unmeritorious submissions on resisting summary judgment.
Key takeaways
This judgment highlights that refusing to pay an adjudicator’s fees can have significant and costly consequences. Here, the Court demonstrated that unpaid fees, costs incurred in recovering unpaid fees, contractual interest and legal costs were all recoverable by the Claimants. Consequently, failing to pay an adjudicator’s fees without good reason may substantially increase the overall liability for the paying party, far beyond the original amount payable.
Need more clarity on adjudication? Don’t hesitate to get in touch. Our team is on hand to offer clear and commercial legal support.
This article contains information of general interest about current legal issues, but does not provide legal advice. It is prepared for the general information of our clients and other interested parties. This article should not be relied upon in any specific situation without appropriate legal advice. If you require legal advice on any of the issues raised in this article, please contact one of our specialist construction lawyers.
© Hawkswell Kilvington Limited 2026